Qabasat

Qabasat

An Analysis and Criticism of William Stoeger’s Solution to the Question of the Divine Act on the Basis of the ‘Transcendental Wisdom’ [Theory]

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Assistant Professor of Mo’asseseh Amuzeshi va Pajuheshi Imam Khomeini, group of philosophy of religion
2 Ph.D Student of Philosophy of Religion, Pajuheshqah Farhanq va Andisheh Islami
0699
Abstract
The research of this article starts with confronting the following question: “can we have an understanding of the Divine act in the world such that it does not lead to abandoning the legality of causality legality in the world.
After investigating the most important points present in the changes of’ the concept of God and His act from the past to today, I will first explain the most promising theories posed in the present century, i.e. the theory of Russell and Polkinghorne; then studying the capacity of Stoeger’s idea, I will criticize these theories and inspect their insights and defects. Then considering Allameh Tabataba’i's understanding of the kind of God’s existence and activity in the world on the basis of the [theory of] ‘transcendental wisdom’, I will criticize Stoeger’s theory while its insights and useful points are preserved. Among these discussions I have selected my own theory which tries to collect all the positive characteristics of the previous ideas.
According to this theory, God is an agent who has created a lawful world and has given all its present characteristics, relations and rules; this agency is along with His act of creation. On the other hand, He has a continuous and permanent presence in the world for the rest of its existence because this world is ‘mere relation’ [to God] and is thoroughly poverty and needs donation of existence in each and every second. Thus God’s activity is not restricted to the instant of creation. Accepting this perspective, we may get rid of the deistic problems posed regarding some previous ideas such as the classical physics of Newton.
Keywords

  1. آرمسترانگ، دیوید؛ چیستی قانون طبیعت؛ مقدمه و ترجمه امیر دیوانی، ویراسته مصطفی ملکیان؛ قم: پژوهشگاه حوزه و دانشگاه، 1392.
  2. باربور، ایان؛ دین و علم؛ ترجمه پیروز فطورچی؛ تهران: پژوهشگاه فرهنگ و اندیشه اسلامی، 1392.
  3. خاکی قراملکی، محمدرضا؛ تحلیل هویت علم دینی و علم مدرن؛ چ3، قم: کتاب فردا، 1391.
  4. طباطبایی، سید محمدحسین؛ معنویت تشیع؛ چ6، قم: تشیع، 1387.
  5. ــــــ؛ المیزان فی تفسیر القرآن؛ ج 1، چ5، قم: دفتر انتشارات اسلامی جامعه مدرسین حوزه علمیه قم، 1417 ق.
  6. مطهری، مرتضی؛ نبوت؛ چ22، تهران: صدرا، 1389.
  7. یغمایی، ابوتراب؛ «فعل الهی غیرمداخله‌گرایانه و نظریه علیت نوصدرایی»، اندیشه دینی؛ ش61، زمستان 1395.
    1. Edwards, Denis; "Toward a Theology of Divine Action: William R. Stoeger, S.J., on the Laws of Nature", Theological Studies; 2015, Vol.76(3), 2015, pp.485–502.
    2. McGrath, A. E.; Christian Theology: An Introduction; Wiley Blackwell, 2021.
    3. Monton, Bradley; "God acts in the quantum‌ world‌"; in J. Kvanvig and J.L. Kvanvig (eds.); Oxford Studies in Philosophy of Religion; 5: OUP Oxford, 2014, pp.84-167.
    4. Plantinga, A.; Where the Conflict Really Lies: Science, Religion, and Naturalism; Oxford University Press, USA, 2011.
    5. Polkinghorne, J. C.; "Physical Process, Quantum Events‌, and‌ Divine Agency"; in R. J. Russell‌, et‌ al. (eds.); Quantum Mechanics: Scientific Perspectives on Divine Action; 2001.
    6. _____; Quarks, Chaos & Christianity: Questions to Science and Religion, Crossroad Publishing Company, 2005.
    7. _____; "Quantum Theology", in‌ R. J. Russell‌, T. Peters, and N. Hallanger (eds.); God’s Action in Nature's World: Essays in, 2006.
    8. Honour of Robert John Russell, Ashgate Pub.
    9. _____; "The Metaphysics of Divine Action", in F. L. R. Shults, N. C. Murphy‌, and‌ R. J. Russell (eds‌.); Philosophy, Science and Divine Action; Brill, 2009.
    10. Russell, R.J., Murphy, N. C., and Isham, C. J.; Quantum cosmology and the‌ laws‌ of nature: scientific perspectives on divine action; Vatican Observatory, 1993.
    11. Russell, R. J., et al; Chaos and Complexity: Scientific Perspectives on Divine Action; Vatican Observatory,1995.
    12. Russell, R. J., et al; Evolutionary and‌ Molecular Biology: Scientific Perspectives on Divine Action; Vatican Observatory, 1998.
    13. Russell‌, R. J., Neuroscience and the Person: Scientific Perspectives on Divine Action; Vatican Observatory, 1999.
    14. Russell, R. J., et al.; Quantum Mechanics: Scientific Perspectives on Divine Action; Vatican Observatory, 2001.
    15. Russell, R. J., "Five key topics ‌‌on‌ the frontier of theology and science today", Dialog, 2007.
    16. Russell, R. J., Murphy, N. C., and Stoeger, William R. (eds.); Scientific‌ Perspectives on Divine Action: Twenty Years of Challenge and Progress; 1edn., Rome: Vatican Observatory FND NDUP, 2008.
    17. Stoeger William R.; “The Mind–Brain Problem, the Laws of Nature, and Constitutive Relationships”, in Neuroscience and the Person: Scientific Perspectives on Divine Action; ed. Robert John Russell et al.; Vatican City: Vatican Observatory; Berkeley CA: CTNS, 1999, pp.129–46.
    18. _____; Epistemological and Ontological Issues Arising from Quantum Theory, in Quantum Mechanics: Scientific Perspectives on Divine Action; ed. Robert John Russell et al., Vatican City: Vatican Observatory; Berkeley CA: CTNS, 2001)
    19. _____; “Contemporary Physics and the Ontological Status of the Laws of Nature”, in Quantum Cosmology and the Laws of Nature: scientific perspectives on divine action; ed. Russell, R. J., Murphy, N. C., and Isham, C. J.; 1993, Vatican Observatory.
    20. _____; “Describing God’s Action in the World in Light of Scientific Knowledge of Reality”, in Chaos and Complexity: Scientific Perspectives on Divine Action; ed. Robert John Russell, Nancey Murphy, and Arthur R. Peacocke; Vatican City: Vatican Observatory; Berkeley, CA: CTNS, 1995.